Username:
Password:
Forgot your password ? click here
(Cancel)
  • Auto123.com
  • Auto-Venus.com
  • Racing
  • V12
  • Moto123.com
  • Used123.ca
  • Subscribe to our newsletter
Auto123.com - Automotive Instinct
Auto123.comCanada•Français
Where are you from? auto123
      |  Cancel
 
Oops! Your postal code does not seem to exist on earth. Can you try again?
  • Open a session
  • Become a member!
Forgot your password?
 
New Used Reviews News Parts & Maintenance Racing Photos & videos
  • Home
  • Racing
  • Article
    • Print
Share  
  • F1
  • NASCAR
  • IndyCar
  • North American Series
  • European Series
  • Canadian Series
  • Rally
  • Karting
  • Other News
Related
  • Racing
  • Standings
  • Photos
  • Videos
Community
  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Community Page
  • RSS Feeds
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • Youtube
  • Friendfeed
  • Tumblr

F1: Stewards stripped Hamilton of Barcelona pole for rule infringement

By Auto123.com,
Sunday, May 13, 2012
Tweet
From GMM

Stewards stripped Lewis Hamilton of pole position for the Spanish grand prix.

"This is such a disappointment. Today's qualifying session was one of the best I've ever driven," said the 2008 world champion, who has been relegated to the very back of the grid.

His McLaren engineer had instructed him to stop on the track with a "problem" after completing his pole lap.

It emerges that the team was worried Hamilton would not have enough fuel left in the car for the mandatory 1 litre FIA sample.

But rule 6.6.2 requires drivers to return to the pits after qualifying under their own power.

Sam Michael, the sporting director, argued a case of 'force majeure'.

The stewards said in a statement: "As the amount of fuel put into the car is under the complete control of the competitor the stewards cannot accept this as a case of force majeure."

"Since we accept that the stewards didn't agree with our interpretation of force majeure, we didn't contest their decision to penalise him," said team boss Martin Whitmarsh.

It means Pastor Maldonado inherits his first pole; the first for Williams since Nico Hulkenberg in 2010.

UPDATE: Following Hamilton's penalty the whole of the paddock reacted.

The Sun newspaper refer to the incident as a draconian "24-place grid penalty" imposed by the FIA after an "astonishing cock-up" by McLaren.

Writing in the Telegraph, Tom Cary said the severity of the disqualification "raised eyebrows", but agreed that "McLaren's mistake was horrendous".

He said it has been "a season of errors" by the famous British team, who are yet to get Hamilton's signature on a new contract beyond 2012.

"Hamilton must be seething," read an article in the Daily Mail newspaper, while The Times laid out McLaren's "catalogue of errors".

27-year-old Hamilton's "raw talent is being thwarted by mishap and cock-up," said journalist Kevin Eason.

"McLaren are lovely people but how the hell do they get themselves in this position?" wrote the Mirror's Byron Young on Twitter.

Even the non-English language media agreed.

"It was another great mistake by McLaren that could eventually cost Hamilton the championship," wrote Livio Oricchio in O Estado de S.Paulo.

Italy's La Stampa called McLaren's fuel gaffe a case of "harakiri".

Germany's Auto Motor und Sport added: "It was error number 13 for McLaren since last year".

While highly critical of McLaren's own-goal, however, the feeling in the paddock is that the stewards' penalty - although accepted by McLaren - was overly harsh.

"Back of the grid? Way, way too harsh", added Young on Twitter.

"Draconian penalty in my view," agreed PA Sport's Ian Parkes. "Dropping Q3 time would have sufficed."

Sky commentator Martin Brundle added: "(I) feel they should have deleted that (Q3) laptime only which would have put him sixth".

And excluding Hamilton from Q3 altogether would have put him 11th. Now, he will be "lucky to score a point", Auto Motor und Sport predicted.

In the Independent, however, David Tremayne noted: "Welcome to the draconian world of F1."

David Croft, the lead Sky commentator, said the FIA stewards had acted correctly.

"A good rule should be one that covers all eventualities with a penalty that acts as a deterrent which in this case is what happened.

"Too little fuel can't be tolerated," he added. "It seems harsh but had Lewis taken pole by one thousandth of a second, would it be harsh then?"

The Spanish fans - not Hamilton's biggest supporters dating back to his spats with Fernando Alonso in 2007 - were happy.

Asked on the El Mundo website whether the penalty was fair, 76 per cent answered yes.
Topics: lewis hamilton, mclaren, race car driver, racing
 Email
 Print
 
 
 
 
 
 Save
 More...
User Rating: 
Rate it:
You must log in before rating this.
You have already rated this.
Thank you

Recent Articles

  • F1: Red Bull Racing to rename Renault engines 'Infiniti' next year

    May 24, 2013 by Auto123.com

  • F1: Gerhard Berger says Toro Rosso drivers not ready for Red Bull Racing

    May 24, 2013 by Auto123.com

  • F1: Bernie Ecclestone asks Kimi Raikkonen to stop Hunt tribute

    May 24, 2013 by Auto123.com

  • F1: Toro Rosso's engine deal with Renault apparently not done yet

    May 24, 2013 by Auto123.com

  • F1 Monaco: Mark Webber not overly concerned by lack of Red Bull pace

    May 24, 2013 by George East

blog comments powered by Disqus

Racing Multimedia

  • Videos
  • Photos
F1 Canada: Formula 1 comes to Montreal Video
F1 Canada: Formula 1 comes to Montreal Video
Mon, Jun 04, 2012
(0:35)
F1 Canada: Formula 1 comes to Montreal Video
Race cars on display at the Detroit Auto Show Video
NASCAR Montreal: Video of Maryeve Dufault's first Nationwide race Video
Video of the NASCAR Canadian Tire race in Trois-Rivieres Video
NASCAR: Video of the pit stop practices with Michael Waltrip Racing Video
Fancy aerodynamics of NASCAR race cars Video
Looking at the interior of a NASCAR race car! Video
Video: Inside the striking NASCAR team haulers Video
Video: 75th anniversary of the famous Silver Arrow Video
Video Search
All Videos
F1 Spain: Celebrating Fernando Alonso's victory in Barcelona (+photos)
F1 Spain: Celebrating Fernando Alonso's victory in Barcelona (+photos)
The Spanish crowd got what they wanted Sunday at the Circuit de Catalunya for the Grand prix of Spain, as Fernando Alonso drove brilliantly to secure his first win here in Barcelona since 2006.
  • Photo Gallery
  • Article
F1 Spain: Celebrating Fernando Alonso's victory in Barcelona (+photos)

IndyCar: Photo gallery of James Hinchcliffe's win in Sao Paulo (+photos)

DTM: Photo gallery of Augusto Farfus' win at Hockenheim (+photos)

GT: Photo gallery of the Coupes de Pâques at Nogaro (+photos)

IndyCar: Photo gallery of James Hinchcliffe's first win (+photos)

F1 Australia: A perfect race for Kimi Raikkonen in Australia (+photos)

NASCAR: Photo gallery of Jimmie Johnson's win at Daytona 500 (+photos)

F1 Brazil: Photo gallery of Button's win and Vettel's third world title (+photos)

F1 USA: Photo gallery of Lewis Hamilton's victory in Texas

NASCAR: Photo gallery of Brad Keselowski's first Sprint Cup title

F1 Abu Dhabi: Photo gallery of Kimi Raikkonen's maiden win with Lotus (+photos)

DTM: Photo gallery of Bruno Spengler's championship victory (+photos)

All photos


Other News

F1: Toro Rosso's engine deal with Renault apparently not done yet
Indy 500: Official starting grid of the 2013 Indianapolis 500

Recommendations

Help Navigation Menu

New vehicles

  • Find a car
  • Find a dealer
  • Promotions
  •  
  • Build your car
  • Compare cars

Maintenance

  • Tires
  • Maintenance schedule
  • Car recalls

Used vehicles

  • Advanced search
  • Car recalls
  • See our promotions
  • Compare cars

Photos & videos

  • See our photos & videos
  • Reviews
  • Autoshows
  • Racing

Reviews

  • Read our car reviews

News

  • Read our news & events
Auto123.comCanada•Français
Where are you from? auto123
      |  Cancel
 
Oups! Your postal code does not seem to exist on earth. Can you try again?
X Fermer
Why do we ask?
  • Promotion offers ear you
  • To give you local rates on pricing
  • For relevant searches
  • Local advertising
Where are you from?
Postal code: (first 3 digits)
Your current location: ,US
Auto123.com
Leading Canadian Automotive Portal
Where are you from?
Postal code: (first 3 digits)
Why do we ask?
  • Promotions near you
  • Local rates on pricing
  • Relevant searches
  • Local advertising
Close this window

About Auto123.com

  • Learn more about auto123.com
  • Advertise with us
  • Job offers
  • Partners
  • Contact us

Like

  • Follow @auto123
  •  Consult our videos on YouTube
  •  Watch our photos on Flickr
  •  Our RSS Feeds
  •  Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Back to home page
  • Site map
  • Send your feedback  
  • Report a bug  
  • Auto123.com
  • Auto-Venus.com
  • Racing
  • V12
  • Moto123.com
  • Used123.ca
  • © 2000-2013 Auto123.com  •  All rights reserved.
  • Terms of use
  • Confidentiality policy