Auto123.com - Helping you drive happy

2012 Compact performance car road comparison test

|
Get the best interest rate
Khatir Soltani
Comparo 2.0: These cars will spend 99% of their lives on the road
Compromises
The presence of compromises in cars is a phenomenon that is on its way out. Consider the fact that many of these cars are as quick or handle better than hardcore track-biased production cars that were sold 15 years ago.

As we can see, versatility, comfort and good driving manners need not stand in the way of having a blast in controlled situations. It would seem as though the FR-S got the shaft, but much like the Genesis Coupe in the track test, compromises need not be so evident.

2012 Compact performance car road comparison test
Photo: Sébastien D'Amour

The same goes for refinement. It is no longer pertinent for a car to punish its occupants because it is really good at something. What glorious automotive times we live in.

Be sure to check out our Comparo 2.0 track test of these cars to get the whole story!

At the end of the week, as a group, we did sit down and vote on which car we would take home and call our own. The result was unanimous: The 2013 Subaru BRZ.

Notes:
All of the cars in this test scored high safety marks as they are all equipped with stability and traction control as well as at least six air bags.

 2013 Hyundai Genesis Coupe 2.0T R-Spec2012 Mazda MX-5 SV2013 Scion FR-S2013 Subaru BRZ Sport-Tech2012 VW Golf GTI 5-door
EngineTurbo 2.0L L42.0L L42.0L H42.0L H4Turbo 2.0L L4
Transmission6-speed manual6-speed manual6-speed manual6-speed manual6-speed auto seq
Power (hp @ rpm)274 @ 6,000167 @ 7,000200 @ 7,000200 @ 7,000200 @ 5,100 - 6,000
Torque (lb-ft @ rpm)275 @ 2,000140 @ 5,000151 @ 6,400 - 6,600151 @ 6,400 - 6,600207 @ 1,700 - 5,000
Curb weight (lbs/kg)3,362 / 1,5252,606 / 1,1822,758 / 1,2512,776 / 1,2593,080 / 1,397
Tire make & modelBridgestone Potenza RE050ABridgestone Potenza RE050AMichelin Primacy HPMichelin Primacy HPPirelli P Zero Nero
Tire size (frontP225/45VR19205/45VR17P215/45WR17P215/45WR17225/40HR18
Tire size (rear)P245/40VR19205/45VR17P215/45WR17P215/45WR17225/40HR18

 2013 Hyundai Genesis Coupe 2.0T R-Spec2012 Mazda MX-5 SV2013 Scion FR-S2013 Subaru BRZ Sport-Tech2012 VW Golf GTI 5-door
0-100 km/h (sec)6.58.37.67.26.8
1/4 mile (sec @ km/h)14.5 @ 15615.9 @ 14115.1 @ 15015.0 @ 15214.8 @ 155
Fuel economy (L/100km)10.38.67.78.38.4
Engine @ 100 km/h (rpm)2,3002,9002,7502,7502,100
Braking, 100-0 km/h (m)3841403941

Khatir Soltani
Khatir Soltani
Automotive expert
  • Over 6 years experience as a car reviewer
  • Over 50 test drives in the last year
  • Involved in discussions with virtually every auto manufacturer in Canada