Auto123.com - Helping you drive happy

Test Fest : Best New Convertible

|
Get the best interest rate
Mark Hacking
Open-Air Battle for Top Honours
MORE TEST FEST COVERAGE
Pick-UpNov 15, 2006
SUV / CUV over $60,000Nov 14, 2006
SUV / CUV $35,000 - $60,000Nov 13, 2006
SUV / CUV under $35,000Nov 11, 2006
Sport / performance car over $50,000Nov 9, 2006
Sport / performance car under $50,000Nov 8, 2006
Prestige car over $75,000Nov 7, 2006
Luxury car under $50,000Nov 6, 2006
Family car over $30,000Nov 5, 2006
Family car $22,000 - $30,000Nov 4, 2006
Small car over $18,000 Nov 3, 2006
Small car under $18,000Nov 2, 2006
The most coveted parking space in the countryNov 1, 2006
Writers' predictions for the best new cars of 2007Nov 1, 2006

Open-Air Battle for Top Honours

This year's contenders for top convertible at TestFest have much in common. All four are four-seaters. Two are soft-tops, while two feature retractable hardtops. Two share the same engine and three are front-wheel drive vehicles. The point is: With so many similarities among the Audi A4 Cabriolet, Mitsubishi Eclipse Spyder, Pontiac G6 Convertible and Volkswagen Eos, picking a clear winner can be a challenge.

Audi A4 Cabriolet
Alphabetically speaking, the Audi A4 is first in the order - and it has many characteristics that make it the best among this foursome. The car's
(Photo: Audi)
2.0-litre turbocharged direct-injection engine, shared with the Eos, is a capable one that delivers smooth power (200 hp; 207 lb-ft of torque) and negligible turbo lag.

Unfortunately, due to the Audi's weight, its acceleration was the least impressive of the group: 0 to 100 km/h arrived in a leisurely 8.8 seconds. On the track, the car handled and gripped the surface well - true of all A4s equipped with the quattro system. (It's worth noting that the Audi is the only all-wheel drive entry; the other three are front-wheel drive examples.)

The test version of the A4 Cab came with many high-end features, most notably the 6-speed Tiptronic semi-automatic transmission, Bose sound system and a very nice birch wood trim package. These amenities made the Audi the most luxurious competitor in the group - but also sent its price-as-tested figure soaring to $63,570. At this price, there's little chance the Audi A4 Cabriolet will be declared the winner.

Mitsubishi Eclipse Spyder
Of all the four entries here, the Mitsubishi Eclipse Spyder is the sportiest and most fun to drive. With its 3.8-litre V6 engine developing 260 horsepower and 258 lb-ft of torque, the Eclipse gallops off the line (compared to the other three) to produce a 0-100 km/h time of 6.8
(Photo: Mitsubishi)
seconds. On course, this droptop exhibits a fair amount of understeer (mainly due to weak tires) and a bit too much body roll, but its inherent handling characteristics are very solid.

Inside, the version tested featured all the bells and whistles, including the raucous 650-watt Rockford Fosgate audio system. The space available for front-seat passengers is decent, but the backseat legroom is all but non-existent. The Eclipse Spyder is arguably the best-looking of this group with the top down and, with an as-tested price of $36,998, it offers excellent bang for the buck.

Pontiac G6 Convertible
The Pontiac G6 Convertible is a solid effort from General Motors: a high fun-to-drive factor, a trick hardtop convertible and decent value. Powered by a 3.9-litre V6, the G6 motors from a standing start to 100 km/h in 8.2
(Photo: General Motors)
seconds. Although the engine develops a healthy 229 horsepower and 235 lb-ft of torque, the package is hampered by an outdated 4-speed automatic transmission - two speeds fewer than all the other entries.

My opinion of the G6 skyrocketed when I took to the track, though; a sudden rainstorm meant it was the only one in the group that had to contend with a damp surface. The Pontiac's handling and grip were remarkable considering the slippery conditions. The car's composure was, no doubt, aided by the GT Convertible Performance Package, which includes dual chrome tip exhaust, six-way power driver's seat and, more importantly, 18-inch aluminum wheels. Price as tested for the Pontiac G6 Convertible is $39,805.
Mark Hacking
Mark Hacking
Automotive expert
None